feat(core): remove identities (#6809)

packages/core/src/routes/profile/email-and-phone.ts

@@ -0,0 +1,192 @@
+import { emailRegEx, phoneRegEx, UserScope } from '@logto/core-kit';
+import { VerificationType, AccountCenterControlValue, SignInIdentifier } from '@logto/schemas';
+import { z } from 'zod';
+
+import koaGuard from '#src/middleware/koa-guard.js';
+
+import RequestError from '../../errors/RequestError/index.js';
+import { buildVerificationRecordByIdAndType } from '../../libraries/verification.js';
+import assertThat from '../../utils/assert-that.js';
+import type { UserRouter, RouterInitArgs } from '../types.js';
+
+export default function emailAndPhoneRoutes<T extends UserRouter>(...args: RouterInitArgs<T>) {
+  const [router, { queries, libraries }] = args;
+  const {
+    users: { updateUserById, findUserById },
+    signInExperiences: { findDefaultSignInExperience },
+  } = queries;
+
+  const {
+    users: { checkIdentifierCollision },
+  } = libraries;
+
+  router.post(
+    '/profile/primary-email',
+    koaGuard({
+      body: z.object({
+        email: z.string().regex(emailRegEx),
+        newIdentifierVerificationRecordId: z.string(),
+      }),
+      status: [204, 400, 401],
+    }),
+    async (ctx, next) => {
+      const { id: userId, scopes, identityVerified } = ctx.auth;
+      assertThat(
+        identityVerified,
+        new RequestError({ code: 'verification_record.permission_denied', status: 401 })
+      );
+      const { email, newIdentifierVerificationRecordId } = ctx.guard.body;
+      const { fields } = ctx.accountCenter;
+      assertThat(
+        fields.email === AccountCenterControlValue.Edit,
+        'account_center.filed_not_editable'
+      );
+
+      assertThat(scopes.has(UserScope.Email), 'auth.unauthorized');
+
+      // Check new identifier
+      const newVerificationRecord = await buildVerificationRecordByIdAndType({
+        type: VerificationType.EmailVerificationCode,
+        id: newIdentifierVerificationRecordId,
+        queries,
+        libraries,
+      });
+      assertThat(newVerificationRecord.isVerified, 'verification_record.not_found');
+      assertThat(newVerificationRecord.identifier.value === email, 'verification_record.not_found');
+
+      await checkIdentifierCollision({ primaryEmail: email }, userId);
+
+      const updatedUser = await updateUserById(userId, { primaryEmail: email });
+
+      ctx.appendDataHookContext('User.Data.Updated', { user: updatedUser });
+
+      ctx.status = 204;
+
+      return next();
+    }
+  );
+
+  router.delete(
+    '/profile/primary-email',
+    koaGuard({
+      status: [204, 400, 401],
+    }),
+    async (ctx, next) => {
+      const { id: userId, scopes, identityVerified } = ctx.auth;
+      assertThat(
+        identityVerified,
+        new RequestError({ code: 'verification_record.permission_denied', status: 401 })
+      );
+      const { fields } = ctx.accountCenter;
+      assertThat(
+        fields.email === AccountCenterControlValue.Edit,
+        'account_center.filed_not_editable'
+      );
+
+      assertThat(scopes.has(UserScope.Email), 'auth.unauthorized');
+
+      const { signUp } = await findDefaultSignInExperience();
+
+      if (signUp.identifiers.includes(SignInIdentifier.Email)) {
+        // If email is the only sign-up identifier, we need to keep the email
+        assertThat(signUp.identifiers.includes(SignInIdentifier.Phone), 'user.email_required');
+        // If phone is also a sign-up identifier, check if phone is set
+        const user = await findUserById(userId);
+        assertThat(user.primaryPhone, 'user.email_or_phone_required');
+      }
+
+      const updatedUser = await updateUserById(userId, { primaryEmail: null });
+
+      ctx.appendDataHookContext('User.Data.Updated', { user: updatedUser });
+
+      ctx.status = 204;
+
+      return next();
+    }
+  );
+
+  router.post(
+    '/profile/primary-phone',
+    koaGuard({
+      body: z.object({
+        phone: z.string().regex(phoneRegEx),
+        newIdentifierVerificationRecordId: z.string(),
+      }),
+      status: [204, 400, 401],
+    }),
+    async (ctx, next) => {
+      const { id: userId, scopes, identityVerified } = ctx.auth;
+      assertThat(
+        identityVerified,
+        new RequestError({ code: 'verification_record.permission_denied', status: 401 })
+      );
+      const { phone, newIdentifierVerificationRecordId } = ctx.guard.body;
+      const { fields } = ctx.accountCenter;
+      assertThat(
+        fields.phone === AccountCenterControlValue.Edit,
+        'account_center.filed_not_editable'
+      );
+
+      assertThat(scopes.has(UserScope.Phone), 'auth.unauthorized');
+
+      // Check new identifier
+      const newVerificationRecord = await buildVerificationRecordByIdAndType({
+        type: VerificationType.PhoneVerificationCode,
+        id: newIdentifierVerificationRecordId,
+        queries,
+        libraries,
+      });
+      assertThat(newVerificationRecord.isVerified, 'verification_record.not_found');
+      assertThat(newVerificationRecord.identifier.value === phone, 'verification_record.not_found');
+
+      await checkIdentifierCollision({ primaryPhone: phone }, userId);
+
+      const updatedUser = await updateUserById(userId, { primaryPhone: phone });
+
+      ctx.appendDataHookContext('User.Data.Updated', { user: updatedUser });
+
+      ctx.status = 204;
+
+      return next();
+    }
+  );
+
+  router.delete(
+    '/profile/primary-phone',
+    koaGuard({
+      status: [204, 400, 401],
+    }),
+    async (ctx, next) => {
+      const { id: userId, scopes, identityVerified } = ctx.auth;
+      assertThat(
+        identityVerified,
+        new RequestError({ code: 'verification_record.permission_denied', status: 401 })
+      );
+      const { fields } = ctx.accountCenter;
+      assertThat(
+        fields.phone === AccountCenterControlValue.Edit,
+        'account_center.filed_not_editable'
+      );
+
+      assertThat(scopes.has(UserScope.Phone), 'auth.unauthorized');
+
+      const { signUp } = await findDefaultSignInExperience();
+
+      if (signUp.identifiers.includes(SignInIdentifier.Phone)) {
+        // If phone is the only sign-up identifier, we need to keep the phone
+        assertThat(signUp.identifiers.includes(SignInIdentifier.Email), 'user.phone_required');
+        // If email is also a sign-up identifier, check if email is set
+        const user = await findUserById(userId);
+        assertThat(user.primaryEmail, 'user.email_or_phone_required');
+      }
+
+      const updatedUser = await updateUserById(userId, { primaryPhone: null });
+
+      ctx.appendDataHookContext('User.Data.Updated', { user: updatedUser });
+
+      ctx.status = 204;
+
+      return next();
+    }
+  );
+}

packages/core/src/routes/profile/index.openapi.json

@@ -174,6 +174,16 @@
             "description": "Permission denied, the verification record is invalid."
           }
         }
+      },
+      "delete": {
+        "operationId": "DeletePrimaryEmail",
+        "summary": "Delete primary email",
+        "description": "Delete primary email for the user, a verification-record-id in header is required for checking sensitive permissions.",
+        "responses": {
+          "204": {
+            "description": "The primary email was deleted successfully."
+          }
+        }
       }
     },
     "/api/profile/primary-phone": {
@@ -208,6 +218,16 @@
             "description": "Permission denied, the verification record is invalid."
           }
         }
+      },
+      "delete": {
+        "operationId": "DeletePrimaryPhone",
+        "summary": "Delete primary phone",
+        "description": "Delete primary phone for the user, a verification-record-id in header is required for checking sensitive permissions.",
+        "responses": {
+          "204": {
+            "description": "The primary phone was deleted successfully."
+          }
+        }
       }
     },
     "/api/profile/identities": {

packages/core/src/routes/profile/index.ts

@@ -1,9 +1,9 @@
-import { emailRegEx, phoneRegEx, usernameRegEx, UserScope } from '@logto/core-kit';
+import { usernameRegEx, UserScope } from '@logto/core-kit';
 import {
-  VerificationType,
   userProfileResponseGuard,
   userProfileGuard,
   AccountCenterControlValue,
+  SignInIdentifier,
 } from '@logto/schemas';
 import { z } from 'zod';
 
@@ -12,11 +12,11 @@ import koaGuard from '#src/middleware/koa-guard.js';
 import { EnvSet } from '../../env-set/index.js';
 import RequestError from '../../errors/RequestError/index.js';
 import { encryptUserPassword } from '../../libraries/user.utils.js';
-import { buildVerificationRecordByIdAndType } from '../../libraries/verification.js';
 import assertThat from '../../utils/assert-that.js';
 import { PasswordValidator } from '../experience/classes/libraries/password-validator.js';
 import type { UserRouter, RouterInitArgs } from '../types.js';
 
+import emailAndPhoneRoutes from './email-and-phone.js';
 import identitiesRoutes from './identities.js';
 import koaAccountCenter from './middlewares/koa-account-center.js';
 import { getAccountCenterFilteredProfile, getScopedProfile } from './utils/get-scoped-profile.js';
@@ -24,7 +24,7 @@ import { getAccountCenterFilteredProfile, getScopedProfile } from './utils/get-s
 export default function profileRoutes<T extends UserRouter>(...args: RouterInitArgs<T>) {
   const [router, { queries, libraries }] = args;
   const {
-    users: { updateUserById, findUserById, deleteUserIdentity },
+    users: { updateUserById, findUserById },
     signInExperiences: { findDefaultSignInExperience },
   } = queries;
 
@@ -58,7 +58,7 @@ export default function profileRoutes<T extends UserRouter>(...args: RouterInitA
       body: z.object({
         name: z.string().nullable().optional(),
         avatar: z.string().url().nullable().optional(),
-        username: z.string().regex(usernameRegEx).optional(),
+        username: z.string().regex(usernameRegEx).nullable().optional(),
       }),
       response: userProfileResponseGuard.partial(),
       status: [200, 400, 422],
@@ -84,7 +84,15 @@ export default function profileRoutes<T extends UserRouter>(...args: RouterInitA
       assertThat(scopes.has(UserScope.Profile), 'auth.unauthorized');
 
       if (username !== undefined) {
-        await checkIdentifierCollision({ username }, userId);
+        if (username === null) {
+          const { signUp } = await findDefaultSignInExperience();
+          assertThat(
+            !signUp.identifiers.includes(SignInIdentifier.Username),
+            'user.username_required'
+          );
+        } else {
+          await checkIdentifierCollision({ username }, userId);
+        }
       }
 
       const updatedUser = await updateUserById(userId, {
@@ -175,97 +183,6 @@ export default function profileRoutes<T extends UserRouter>(...args: RouterInitA
     }
   );
 
-  router.post(
-    '/profile/primary-email',
-    koaGuard({
-      body: z.object({
-        email: z.string().regex(emailRegEx),
-        newIdentifierVerificationRecordId: z.string(),
-      }),
-      status: [204, 400, 401],
-    }),
-    async (ctx, next) => {
-      const { id: userId, scopes, identityVerified } = ctx.auth;
-      assertThat(
-        identityVerified,
-        new RequestError({ code: 'verification_record.permission_denied', status: 401 })
-      );
-      const { email, newIdentifierVerificationRecordId } = ctx.guard.body;
-      const { fields } = ctx.accountCenter;
-      assertThat(
-        fields.email === AccountCenterControlValue.Edit,
-        'account_center.filed_not_editable'
-      );
-
-      assertThat(scopes.has(UserScope.Email), 'auth.unauthorized');
-
-      // Check new identifier
-      const newVerificationRecord = await buildVerificationRecordByIdAndType({
-        type: VerificationType.EmailVerificationCode,
-        id: newIdentifierVerificationRecordId,
-        queries,
-        libraries,
-      });
-      assertThat(newVerificationRecord.isVerified, 'verification_record.not_found');
-      assertThat(newVerificationRecord.identifier.value === email, 'verification_record.not_found');
-
-      await checkIdentifierCollision({ primaryEmail: email }, userId);
-
-      const updatedUser = await updateUserById(userId, { primaryEmail: email });
-
-      ctx.appendDataHookContext('User.Data.Updated', { user: updatedUser });
-
-      ctx.status = 204;
-
-      return next();
-    }
-  );
-
-  router.post(
-    '/profile/primary-phone',
-    koaGuard({
-      body: z.object({
-        phone: z.string().regex(phoneRegEx),
-        newIdentifierVerificationRecordId: z.string(),
-      }),
-      status: [204, 400, 401],
-    }),
-    async (ctx, next) => {
-      const { id: userId, scopes, identityVerified } = ctx.auth;
-      assertThat(
-        identityVerified,
-        new RequestError({ code: 'verification_record.permission_denied', status: 401 })
-      );
-      const { phone, newIdentifierVerificationRecordId } = ctx.guard.body;
-      const { fields } = ctx.accountCenter;
-      assertThat(
-        fields.phone === AccountCenterControlValue.Edit,
-        'account_center.filed_not_editable'
-      );
-
-      assertThat(scopes.has(UserScope.Phone), 'auth.unauthorized');
-
-      // Check new identifier
-      const newVerificationRecord = await buildVerificationRecordByIdAndType({
-        type: VerificationType.PhoneVerificationCode,
-        id: newIdentifierVerificationRecordId,
-        queries,
-        libraries,
-      });
-      assertThat(newVerificationRecord.isVerified, 'verification_record.not_found');
-      assertThat(newVerificationRecord.identifier.value === phone, 'verification_record.not_found');
-
-      await checkIdentifierCollision({ primaryPhone: phone }, userId);
-
-      const updatedUser = await updateUserById(userId, { primaryPhone: phone });
-
-      ctx.appendDataHookContext('User.Data.Updated', { user: updatedUser });
-
-      ctx.status = 204;
-
-      return next();
-    }
-  );
-
+  emailAndPhoneRoutes(...args);
   identitiesRoutes(...args);
 }

packages/integration-tests/src/api/profile.ts

@@ -24,6 +24,11 @@ export const updatePrimaryEmail = async (
     headers: { [verificationRecordIdHeader]: verificationRecordId },
   });
 
+export const deletePrimaryEmail = async (api: KyInstance, verificationRecordId: string) =>
+  api.delete('api/profile/primary-email', {
+    headers: { [verificationRecordIdHeader]: verificationRecordId },
+  });
+
 export const updatePrimaryPhone = async (
   api: KyInstance,
   phone: string,
@@ -35,6 +40,11 @@ export const updatePrimaryPhone = async (
     headers: { [verificationRecordIdHeader]: verificationRecordId },
   });
 
+export const deletePrimaryPhone = async (api: KyInstance, verificationRecordId: string) =>
+  api.delete('api/profile/primary-phone', {
+    headers: { [verificationRecordIdHeader]: verificationRecordId },
+  });
+
 export const updateIdentities = async (
   api: KyInstance,
   verificationRecordId: string,

packages/integration-tests/src/tests/api/profile/email-and-phone.test.ts

@@ -3,7 +3,13 @@ import { SignInIdentifier } from '@logto/schemas';
 
 import { enableAllAccountCenterFields } from '#src/api/account-center.js';
 import { authedAdminApi } from '#src/api/api.js';
-import { getUserInfo, updatePrimaryEmail, updatePrimaryPhone } from '#src/api/profile.js';
+import {
+  deletePrimaryEmail,
+  deletePrimaryPhone,
+  getUserInfo,
+  updatePrimaryEmail,
+  updatePrimaryPhone,
+} from '#src/api/profile.js';
 import {
   createAndVerifyVerificationCode,
   createVerificationRecordByPassword,
@@ -135,6 +141,102 @@ describe('profile (email and phone)', () => {
     });
   });
 
+  describe('DELETE /profile/primary-email', () => {
+    it('should fail if scope is missing', async () => {
+      const { user, username, password } = await createDefaultTenantUserWithPassword();
+      const api = await signInAndGetUserApi(username, password);
+      const verificationRecordId = await createVerificationRecordByPassword(api, password);
+
+      await expectRejects(deletePrimaryEmail(api, verificationRecordId), {
+        code: 'auth.unauthorized',
+        status: 400,
+      });
+
+      await deleteDefaultTenantUser(user.id);
+    });
+
+    it('should fail if verification record is invalid', async () => {
+      const { user, username, password } = await createDefaultTenantUserWithPassword();
+      const api = await signInAndGetUserApi(username, password, {
+        scopes: [UserScope.Profile, UserScope.Email],
+      });
+
+      await expectRejects(deletePrimaryEmail(api, 'invalid-verification-record-id'), {
+        code: 'verification_record.permission_denied',
+        status: 401,
+      });
+
+      await deleteDefaultTenantUser(user.id);
+    });
+
+    it('should fail if email is the only sign-up identifier', async () => {
+      const { user, username, password } = await createDefaultTenantUserWithPassword();
+      const api = await signInAndGetUserApi(username, password, {
+        scopes: [UserScope.Profile, UserScope.Email],
+      });
+      const verificationRecordId = await createVerificationRecordByPassword(api, password);
+      await enableAllPasswordSignInMethods({
+        identifiers: [SignInIdentifier.Email],
+        password: true,
+        verify: true,
+      });
+
+      await expectRejects(deletePrimaryEmail(api, verificationRecordId), {
+        code: 'user.email_required',
+        status: 400,
+      });
+
+      await enableAllPasswordSignInMethods();
+      await deleteDefaultTenantUser(user.id);
+    });
+
+    it('should fail if email or phone is the sign-up identifier', async () => {
+      const { user, username, password } = await createDefaultTenantUserWithPassword();
+      const api = await signInAndGetUserApi(username, password, {
+        scopes: [UserScope.Profile, UserScope.Email],
+      });
+      const verificationRecordId = await createVerificationRecordByPassword(api, password);
+      await enableAllPasswordSignInMethods({
+        identifiers: [SignInIdentifier.Email, SignInIdentifier.Phone],
+        password: true,
+        verify: true,
+      });
+
+      await expectRejects(deletePrimaryEmail(api, verificationRecordId), {
+        code: 'user.email_or_phone_required',
+        status: 400,
+      });
+
+      await enableAllPasswordSignInMethods();
+      await deleteDefaultTenantUser(user.id);
+    });
+
+    it('should be able to delete primary email', async () => {
+      const { user, username, password } = await createDefaultTenantUserWithPassword();
+      const api = await signInAndGetUserApi(username, password, {
+        scopes: [UserScope.Profile, UserScope.Email],
+      });
+      const verificationRecordId = await createVerificationRecordByPassword(api, password);
+      const newEmail = generateEmail();
+      const newVerificationRecordId = await createAndVerifyVerificationCode(api, {
+        type: SignInIdentifier.Email,
+        value: newEmail,
+      });
+
+      await updatePrimaryEmail(api, newEmail, verificationRecordId, newVerificationRecordId);
+
+      const userInfo = await getUserInfo(api);
+      expect(userInfo).toHaveProperty('primaryEmail', newEmail);
+
+      await deletePrimaryEmail(api, verificationRecordId);
+
+      const userInfoAfterDelete = await getUserInfo(api);
+      expect(userInfoAfterDelete).toHaveProperty('primaryEmail', null);
+
+      await deleteDefaultTenantUser(user.id);
+    });
+  });
+
   describe('POST /profile/primary-phone', () => {
     it('should fail if scope is missing', async () => {
       const { user, username, password } = await createDefaultTenantUserWithPassword();
@@ -241,4 +343,100 @@ describe('profile (email and phone)', () => {
       await deleteDefaultTenantUser(user.id);
     });
   });
+
+  describe('DELETE /profile/primary-phone', () => {
+    it('should fail if scope is missing', async () => {
+      const { user, username, password } = await createDefaultTenantUserWithPassword();
+      const api = await signInAndGetUserApi(username, password);
+      const verificationRecordId = await createVerificationRecordByPassword(api, password);
+
+      await expectRejects(deletePrimaryPhone(api, verificationRecordId), {
+        code: 'auth.unauthorized',
+        status: 400,
+      });
+
+      await deleteDefaultTenantUser(user.id);
+    });
+
+    it('should fail if verification record is invalid', async () => {
+      const { user, username, password } = await createDefaultTenantUserWithPassword();
+      const api = await signInAndGetUserApi(username, password, {
+        scopes: [UserScope.Profile, UserScope.Phone],
+      });
+
+      await expectRejects(deletePrimaryPhone(api, 'invalid-verification-record-id'), {
+        code: 'verification_record.permission_denied',
+        status: 401,
+      });
+
+      await deleteDefaultTenantUser(user.id);
+    });
+
+    it('should fail if phone is the only sign-up identifier', async () => {
+      const { user, username, password } = await createDefaultTenantUserWithPassword();
+      const api = await signInAndGetUserApi(username, password, {
+        scopes: [UserScope.Profile, UserScope.Phone],
+      });
+      const verificationRecordId = await createVerificationRecordByPassword(api, password);
+      await enableAllPasswordSignInMethods({
+        identifiers: [SignInIdentifier.Phone],
+        password: true,
+        verify: true,
+      });
+
+      await expectRejects(deletePrimaryPhone(api, verificationRecordId), {
+        code: 'user.phone_required',
+        status: 400,
+      });
+
+      await enableAllPasswordSignInMethods();
+      await deleteDefaultTenantUser(user.id);
+    });
+
+    it('should fail if email or phone is the sign-up identifier', async () => {
+      const { user, username, password } = await createDefaultTenantUserWithPassword();
+      const api = await signInAndGetUserApi(username, password, {
+        scopes: [UserScope.Profile, UserScope.Phone],
+      });
+      const verificationRecordId = await createVerificationRecordByPassword(api, password);
+      await enableAllPasswordSignInMethods({
+        identifiers: [SignInIdentifier.Email, SignInIdentifier.Phone],
+        password: true,
+        verify: true,
+      });
+
+      await expectRejects(deletePrimaryPhone(api, verificationRecordId), {
+        code: 'user.email_or_phone_required',
+        status: 400,
+      });
+
+      await enableAllPasswordSignInMethods();
+      await deleteDefaultTenantUser(user.id);
+    });
+
+    it('should be able to delete primary phone', async () => {
+      const { user, username, password } = await createDefaultTenantUserWithPassword();
+      const api = await signInAndGetUserApi(username, password, {
+        scopes: [UserScope.Profile, UserScope.Phone],
+      });
+      const verificationRecordId = await createVerificationRecordByPassword(api, password);
+      const newPhone = generatePhone();
+      const newVerificationRecordId = await createAndVerifyVerificationCode(api, {
+        type: SignInIdentifier.Phone,
+        value: newPhone,
+      });
+
+      await updatePrimaryPhone(api, newPhone, verificationRecordId, newVerificationRecordId);
+
+      const userInfo = await getUserInfo(api);
+      expect(userInfo).toHaveProperty('primaryPhone', newPhone);
+
+      await deletePrimaryPhone(api, verificationRecordId);
+
+      const userInfoAfterDelete = await getUserInfo(api);
+      expect(userInfoAfterDelete).toHaveProperty('primaryPhone', null);
+
+      await deleteDefaultTenantUser(user.id);
+    });
+  });
 });

packages/integration-tests/src/tests/api/profile/index.test.ts

@@ -1,8 +1,9 @@
 import { UserScope } from '@logto/core-kit';
-import { hookEvents } from '@logto/schemas';
+import { hookEvents, SignInIdentifier } from '@logto/schemas';
 
 import { enableAllAccountCenterFields } from '#src/api/account-center.js';
 import { getUserInfo, updateOtherProfile, updatePassword, updateUser } from '#src/api/profile.js';
+import { updateSignInExperience } from '#src/api/sign-in-experience.js';
 import { createVerificationRecordByPassword } from '#src/api/verification-record.js';
 import { WebHookApiTest } from '#src/helpers/hook.js';
 import { expectRejects } from '#src/helpers/index.js';
@@ -174,6 +175,27 @@ describe('profile', () => {
       await deleteDefaultTenantUser(user.id);
     });
 
+    it('should be able to update username to null', async () => {
+      const { user, username, password } = await createDefaultTenantUserWithPassword();
+      const api = await signInAndGetUserApi(username, password);
+
+      await updateSignInExperience({
+        signUp: {
+          identifiers: [SignInIdentifier.Email],
+          password: true,
+          verify: true,
+        },
+      });
+      const response = await updateUser(api, { username: null });
+      expect(response).toMatchObject({ username: null });
+      await enableAllPasswordSignInMethods();
+
+      const userInfo = await getUserInfo(api);
+      expect(userInfo).toHaveProperty('username', null);
+
+      await deleteDefaultTenantUser(user.id);
+    });
+
     it('should fail if username is already in use', async () => {
       const { user, username, password } = await createDefaultTenantUserWithPassword();
       const { user: user2, username: username2 } = await createDefaultTenantUserWithPassword();

packages/phrases/src/locales/en/errors/user.ts

@@ -37,6 +37,11 @@ const user = {
   personal_access_token_name_exists: 'Personal access token name already exists.',
   totp_secret_invalid: 'Invalid TOTP secret supplied.',
   wrong_backup_code_format: 'Backup code format is invalid.',
+  username_required: 'Username is a required identifier, you can not set it to null.',
+  email_or_phone_required:
+    'Email address or phone number is a required identifier, at least one is required.',
+  email_required: 'Email address is a required identifier, you can not set it to null.',
+  phone_required: 'Phone number is a required identifier, you can not set it to null.',
 };
 
 export default Object.freeze(user);